Lieutenant Dan: “Have you found Jesus yet?”

Forrest Gump: “I didn’t know I was supposed to be looking for him, Sir.”

The further I drift down this long and winding road called Christianity, the more I come to realize why I had problems with the Christian tradition for much of my life. One thing that has always been troubling for me is the tendency to speak about religion in the past tense. This past tense discourse treats becoming a Christian as a one-time event or like some sort of ATM transaction in which salvation is withdrawn and secured once and for all. We often use phrases such as “saved” or “born-again” instead of speaking about a journey or an ongoing relationship. We ask if one has “found” Jesus instead of asking if a person is seeking Him.

 

The question “Have you found Jesus?” seems to place Christ on the same level as a lost set of keys which once found, are securely returned to one’s possession. Maybe this is why Forrest responded in the way that he did to Lt. Dan. The question does seem strange when you really think about it. Of course, all Christians want to “find” Jesus. But no matter how hard we try, this is not something that can ever occur in one particular moment. We must continue “finding” or seeking Jesus every day until our last breath. Christ is not a lost wallet or cell phone.

 

Are you saved?” Millions of Americans have been asked this question at some point in their lives. This question, like the one about “finding” Jesus, seems to imply that salvation is achieved at one singular instance. The past tense verb “saved” places this event at a prior time in history. But is salvation really that simple? Can a simple one-time prayer “save” a soul for all eternity? I’m sure most evangelicals would say that it can as long as one remains faithful to that prayer and maintains a sincere relationship with Christ throughout their lives. But then again, this would imply an ongoing process. Therefore, the past tense “saved” would need to be made present since it is a continuation. One is “being saved” or “saving” one’s self through a personal relationship with God.

 

Over the course of this summer, I have been engaged in a serious inquiry into Orthodox Christianity, a topic I discuss here. Orthodox Christians would never ask anyone if they have been “saved.” The Orthodox Church does not expect members to have “found” Jesus, only that they come to church seeking Him. Being “born-again” in Christ is not treated as a one-time transaction. Rather, a Christian in the Orthodox Church is “born-again” at baptism and is continually “reborn” throughout their lives by participating in the liturgy, communion, and prayer. Believers are constantly being renewed or recreated through the organic life of the Church. It is this attitude that makes Orthodoxy appealing to me as someone who previously discounted not only Christianity, but all organized religion.

 

Past tense Christianity creates two major problems. First, it gives some believers a false sense of security. Some Christians may get the impression that they are already “saved” and thus do not need to continue working on their relationship with God. Second, it fails to account for the many diverse methods God uses to work through His children and therefore, tends to shut out many of those who might otherwise seek a relationship with God through the Church. The idea that one must have a “born-again” experience or be “saved” to be an “authentic” Christian divides the body of Christ and ignores the many other ways in which the Holy Spirit manifests itself in the world. It should be noted that I do not discount “born-again” experiences all together. We have all heard stories about those who God rescued from dangerous lives of addiction and excess. We cannot discount these miraculous experiences. On the other hand, we also cannot discount those whom God works through more slowly or who experience the Holy Spirit differently.

 

We must be careful when using past tense language to speak about our faith. Doing so could make us complacent about our relationship to God. Changing the way we speak about Christianity by using the present tense, however, can keep us on our toes. It can make us aware that we always have more work to do. Nearly twelve years ago when I married by beautiful and wonderful wife, I did not triumphantly claim victory and stop working on our relationship. Getting married is only the beginning of a long and winding road. It is the start of a life-long journey. Relationships can only grow stronger with time and effort.

 

8 responses to “Past Tense Christianity”

  1. George Aldhizer Avatar
    George Aldhizer

    Chris, thanks for your important article. I think you are absolutely right to reject the salvation idea popular in fundamentalist Christianity. The Christian life is not made up of one time decisions/prayers, without true repentance that means turning back from our sin, into justification, sanctification, and subsequent glorification in the resurrection.

    I want to push back on your thesis some, and to say that while the fundamentalist vision of salvation that is encompassed by a one off altar call is extremely problematic, there is, for Christians, an initial regeneration. The New Testament has much to say about our initial justification in our faith in Christ that is here! It is now! And the Holy Spirit and all of its fruits is evidence of your conversion. I think it would be very problematic to see salvation as primarily present tense, for our past justification in the righteousness of Christ is what gives Christians hope in the midst of ongoing sin and motivation for continued holiness.

    “But when the goodness and loving kindness of God our Savior appeared, he saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit, whom he poured out on us richly through Jesus Christ our Savior, so that being justified by his grace we might become heirs l according to the hope of eternal life. The saying is trustworthy, and I want you to insist on these things, so that those who have believed in God may be careful to devote themselves to good works”-Titus 3:4-8

    1. Chris Cam Smith Avatar
      Chris Cam Smith

      Thanks George. I think your point is very valid. I guess then we have to ask what is our “initial regeneration.” Is it baptism? A “born-again” experience? Getting “saved” during a church service? A first visit to an Orthodox liturgy? Or can it be simply God speaking to us or warming our hearts as in the case of John Wesley? I would say any of these can be valid along with others even. You do make a good point, a journey cannot begin without the vital first step.

      1. George Aldhizer Avatar
        George Aldhizer

        I think the biblical language would be “for by grace you have been saved through faith” (Eph 2:8). It is our faith in Christ that we point to, while also checking our fruits to make sure they are in accord with the faith in the Christ we proclaim. So, I think that there is strong biblical precedent for having a robust vision of our initial regeneration and justification. I’m not sure if I am disagreeing or agreeing with Lila in saying this (I think her contribution was great), but I think this is a very healthy way of recognizing our election in Christ, of seeing ourselves as the people of God whom He has chosen.

        One that need not (though it certainly may), like you very importantly recognize, have a massive experiential component of heart warming etc. As a Protestant, I want to also caution against “journey” language in discussing salvation. It makes it seem as if we haven’t reached the destination. The Spirit truly brings the righteousness of Christ to us by giving us faith, it is not something we are on a journey towards. Though, that then does come along with, like I think you importantly explain in your article the “already, not yet” tension of scripture that calls us to holiness, to conform to the image of the Son.

  2. Lila Fair Avatar
    Lila Fair

    Excellent points. I think there is also a great tendency to more than complacency– there is a certain cachet implied in saying “I’ve been saved,” as though I now belong to a select class of people; the chosen; the elect. This is where Calvinist teachings (in my opinion) can be misapplied and used to label ourselves and others. There is also the dangerous connotation that “God likes me better than you” because I have achieved or been given a status that others do not have.
    The Christian walk is not a cake walk. It is not membership in the Honor Society. And your warning about complacency should hit home to many of us. In our eagerness to see that others enter into a relationship with Christ, we make of it something it is not. To ask “have you found Jesus?” isn’t an invitation. At best, it offers an opportunity for the other person to share their own journey; at worst, it is a subtle slap in the face, asked in a tone that implies that Jesus can be found (like the keys in your example) but not by you. In between, there is the dangerous assumption that our own “experience” can be (and should be) replicated, in “leading someone to the Lord.” This is another phrase I find troubling among the Christian community. We can and should be witnesses of what God is doing and has done. We should want others to come into fellowship with the Godhead. But we must not rely more on a magical “formula” or “process” than we do on the unique work of the Holy Spirit. We can be used of the Spirit to cause others to rethink their own journey. We can be used to demonstrate mercy, kindness, righteousness, and other aspects of God’s nature. We can testify about our own relationship with Christ– how it began, how it has grown, and is growing, honestly sharing where we stand, etc. In so doing, someone may be encouraged, or convicted by the Holy Spirit working through us to lead them into a renewed relationship with Christ. They may also be angered, made curious, skeptical, contemptuous, etc. Whatever their reaction, it is not our effort, our eloquence or awkwardness, our rhetoric or logic, or even the depth of our feeling or conviction that can “win” a soul to Christ that we should boast. I am especially dismayed at those who claim to have “led” people to the Lord only to abandon them as though they have completed their mission, and this brings me back to your original point about the past tense idea that leading someone to the beginning of a relationship with eternal consequences ends with “hello.” May God forgive us for treating His gift so casually!

    1. Chris Cam Smith Avatar
      Chris Cam Smith

      Thanks Lila for you wonderful comment. Excellent point about winning people over to Christ and then saying “mission accomplished.” If becoming Christian is about a relationship with God, it is also about becoming part of the body of Christ and a relationship with other Christians, one that must be nurtured as well. Terrific thoughts!

      1. David Brown Avatar
        David Brown

        “Transactional” soteriology is a historical product of revivalism, which followed the radical Reformation. (I have really enjoyed and learned a lot from Fr. Stephen Andrew Damick’s podcasts and book, Orthodoxy and Heterodoxy.) How many Decision Cards were filled out tonight?

        I am too lazy to look up any references, but Paul certainly uses all tenses when referring to salvation. Thus the stock answer to “Are you saved?” is “I am saved; I am being saved; and I hope to be saved.” Of course a fancier phrase would be to call it the “Theotic journey.”

        Another saying which causes me to stop and think and ponder is “We are saved together, but we fall alone.” Hmmm…

      2. Chris Cam Smith Avatar
        Chris Cam Smith

        Thanks David for your informative comment. I will definitely check out Fr. Damick’s podcast.

  3. Chris Cam Smith Avatar
    Chris Cam Smith

    I think for many of the televangelist-types, their only concern is the initial conversion. That way they become McDonald’s – over 10 billion served (or whatever the number is up to these days). Counting how many people you’ve converted becomes a sport or a source of pride. Thanks Chris.

Leave a Reply

Conciliar Post

Conciliar Post is an online community and archive devoted to thoughtful Christian reflection. Since its founding, the site has published theological conversations, reflections on Christianity, reviews, and commentary on culture and current events from a Christian perspective.

Top Posts

The Old Testament in OrderDecember 13, 2024Jacob Prahlow
The New Testament in OrderApril 14, 2021Jacob Prahlow
How the Christ Defined the ChristianAugust 15, 2025Matthew Bryan
A Brief History of Communion (Part I)February 14, 2017Jacob Prahlow
The Phoebe ProblemFebruary 16, 2022Jacob Prahlow

Discover more from Conciliar Post

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading