I have seen the purity and beauty of thy perfect law,
the happiness of those in whose heart it reigns,
the calm dignity of the walk to which it calls,
yet I daily violate and contemn its precepts.
Thy loving Spirit strives within me,
brings me Scripture warnings,
speaks in startling providences,
allures by secret whispers,
yet I choose devices and desires to my own hurt,
impiously resent, grieve, and provoke him to abandon me.1

A couple weeks ago, we began looking at Donne’s poem A Hymn to God the Father. With Donne, we wrestled through the question of “Can God forgive me?” In the process, we were drawn back to the fact that God’s forgiveness is not based on us. Rather, it was earned through the life and death of his Son, Jesus Christ. In this fact is glorious freedom. Instead of a relationship that is dependent solely on toeing the line, doting all our i’s and crossing our t’s, we enjoy grace and forgiveness. We are free to love rather than fear, because, as John reminds us, “There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear. For fear has to do with punishment, and whoever fears has not been perfected in love”2 (1 John 4:18).

And yet, I still sin. Quite often, actually, if I’m honest with myself. Donne explains this quandary in the first stanza of A Hymn: “Wilt thou forgive that sin, through which I run, / And do run still: though still I do deplore?”3 Indeed, the same theme seems to come through in the second stanza as well: “Wilt thou forgive that sin which I did shun / A year, or two: but wallowed in, a score?”4 The prayer quoted at the beginning of this article expresses similar struggles. Viewing our current sins, there are three basic responses. For some, the temptation might be to treat God’s grace as a welcome mat to sin. After all, if God’s grace covers my sins, then why worry about them? I’ll live how I want and let Jesus pick up the bill. On the other end of the spectrum, the temptation is to shrink in self-loathing. “How can you keep doing this? What’s wrong with you, don’t you know you ought to live better? You’re doing a terrible job utilizing God’s strength to fight sin!” Neither response accurately understands our true situation, leaving them wide of the mark. The only appropriate response to our sin is repentance. Repentance alone both answers the abstract question, “What about the fact that I keep sinning?” and the practical question, “What should I do now that I have sinned again?”

What is this repentance of which we speak though? Wayne Grudem’s definition is a helpful starting point: “Repentance is a heartfelt sorrow for sin, a renouncing of it, and a sincere commitment to forsake it and walk in obedience to Christ.”5 Looking at Grudem’s definition, there are several aspects deserving further attention. First among these is the fact that repentance is more than an emotional response to our sin. Paul seems to touch on this fact while writing his second letter to the Corinthians: “As it is, I rejoice, not because you were grieved, but because you were grieved into repenting. For you felt a godly grief, so that you suffered no loss through us. For godly grief produces a repentance that leads to salvation without regret, whereas worldly grief produces death” (2 Corinthians 7:9-10). In praising the Corinthians’ grief over their sin, Paul makes clear that their praise was due to the fact that they were “grieved into repenting.” While grief is part of repentance, it is not the sum total. Indeed, to make sure this point is not missed, Paul follows up his praise with the reminder that repentance is what separates godly and worldly grief.

Grudem describes this difference as “a sincere commitment to forsake it [sin] and walk in obedience to Christ.” While there appear to be two parts to this process, turning from sin and turning to Christ, it is more accurate to see them as one motion. In turning away from sin, we also turn towards Christ. Isaiah highlights this in his call to Israel: “Seek the LORD while he may be found; call upon him while he is near; let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts; let him return to the LORD, that he may have compassion on him, and to our God, for he will abundantly pardon” (Isaiah 55:6-7). Merely turning from sin is not enough. There must be a turning back to God. Indeed, if we do not turn to God, at best we will be turning to a new sin, effectively demonstrating that we never turned from sin in the first place.

What difference does repentance make to the questions asked above, though? How does a better understanding of the process of asking for God’s forgiveness affect our assurance of receiving forgiveness? We began answering this question last week with the reminder that God’s forgiveness is ultimately based on Christ’s work, not ours. Building on this answer, it is worth remembering that Scripture constantly points to God’s willingness to forgive. One particularly poetic reminder6 comes from the author of Lamentations. In the midst of his grieving for the destruction that Judah has brought through its sin, the author is able to say, “But this I call to mind, and therefore I have hope: The steadfast love of the LORD never ceases; his mercies never come to an end; they are new every morning; great is your faithfulness. ‘The LORD is my portion,’ says my soul, ‘therefore I will hope in him’ ” (Lamentations 3:21-24). Of our ability to out-sin God’s forgiveness, there is no cause to worry. It is this trust that fights against our temptations towards self loathing—God’s forgiveness and love is freely offered to all who repent. At the same time, this act of repentance also fights against our temptation to use God’s mercy as an excuse to sin. There is no forgiveness for those who plan to continue sinning, for they have never truly repented.

In the end, following Donne’s questions again brings us back to the seriousness and wonder of God’s mercy. It is serious, for it calls us to live a life with fidelity to our King. At the same time though, it contains an inexpressible joy and wonder because this same King is willing to pardon us rebels and bring us back into his household. The closing lines of the prayer quoted earlier capture this attitude of our soul:

All these sins I mourn, lament, and for them cry pardon.
Work in me more profound and abiding repentance;
Give me the fullness of a godly grief
that trembles and fears,
yet ever trusts and loves,
which is ever powerful and ever confident;
Grant that through the tears of repentance
I may see more clearly the brightness
and glories of the saving cross.7

Christian, as we continue life this week, we will undoubtedly encounter sin in our lives. When this happens, may we be quick to sorrow over and turn from our sin, trusting God’s grace both to forgive us and to enable us to live rightly. 

Does the church play a role in helping it’s members with their repentance?
If so, what does this role look like? How can you start putting it into practice?


[wpex more=”View Sources” less=”Hide Sources”]1. “Yet I Sin” in The Valley of Vision: A Collection of Puritan Prayers & Devotions edited by Arthur Bennett (Carlisle: The Banner of Truth Trust, 2006), 125.

2. Scripture quotations are from The Holy Bible, English Standard Version® (ESV®), copyright © 2001 by Crossway. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

3. Donne, John. The Complete English Poems edited by A.J. Smith (London: Penguin Books Ltd, 1996), 348.

4. Ibid, 349.

5. Grudem, Wayne. Systematic Theology: An Introduction to Biblical Doctrine (Leicester: Inter-Varsity Press and Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2000), 713.

6. Others that could be referenced include Deuteronomy 30 and many passages throughout Isaiah and Jeremiah.

7. “Yet I Sin”, 125.

Photo courtesy of Joshua Earle

[/wpex]

2 responses to “Mercy: It’s Seriously Wonderful”

  1. Benjamin Winter Avatar
    Benjamin Winter

    Thanks for highlighting the role of repentance in this way! Have you ever read anything by Catherine Booth? Her sermon on repentance was really moving, as well (here’s a long excerpt):

    REPENTANCE,

    And saying, Repent ye: for the kingdom of Heaven is at band.—MATT.

    iii. 2.

    From that time Jesus began to preach, and to say, Repent: for the

    Kingdom of Heaven is at hand.—MATT. iv. 17.

    “Whereupon, O King Agrippa, I was not disobedient unto the heavenly vision: but shewed first unto them of Damascus, and at Jerusalem, and throughout all the coasts of Judaea, and then to the Gentiles, that they should repent and torn to God, and do works meet for repentance.”—ACTS xxvi. 19,20.

    In the mouths of three witnesses—John the Baptist, Jesus Christ, and the Apostle Paul—this word shall be established, namely, that repentance is an indispensable condition of entering the kingdom of God.

    People generally are all at sea oh this subject, as though insisting that repentance were an arbitrary arrangement on the part of God. I believe God has made human salvation as easy as the Almighty, Infinite mind could make it. But there is a necessity in the case, that we should “repent and turn to God.” It is just as necessary that my feelings be changed and brought to repentance towards God, as it is that the wicked, disobedient boy, should have his feelings brought back into harmony with his father before he can be forgiven. Precisely the same laws of mind are brought into action in both cases, and there is the same necessity in both.

    If there is any father here who has a prodigal son, I ask, How is it that you are not reconciled to your son? You love him—love him intensely. Probably you are more conscious of your love for him than for any other of your children. Your heart yearns over him every day; you pray for him night and day; you dream of him by night; your bowels yearn over your son, and you say, with David, “Absalom, Absalom, my son, my son.” Why are you not reconciled? Why not pat him on the head, or stroke his face, and say, “My dear lad, I am well pleased with you. I love you complacently; I give you my approbation?” Why are you always reproving him? Why are you obliged to hold him at arm’s length? Why can you not live on amicable terms with him? Why can you not have him come in and out, and live with you on the same terms as the affectionate, obedient daughter? “Oh!” you say, “the case is different; I cannot. It is not, ‘I would not;’ but, ‘I cannot.’ Before that can possibly be, the boy’s feelings must be changed towards me. He is at war with me; he has mistaken notions of me; he thinks I am hard, and cruel, and exacting, and severe. I have done all a father could do, but he sees things differently, to what they are, and has harbored these hard feelings against me until he hates me, and will go on in defiance of my will.” You say, “It is a necessity that, as a wise and righteous father, I must insist on a change in him. I cannot receive him as a son, till he comes to my feet. He must confess his sin, and ask me to forgive him. Then, oh! how gladly will my fatherly affection gush out! How I should run to meet him, and put my arms around his neck! but there is a ‘cannot’ in the case.” Just so. It is not that He does not love you, sinner; it is not that the great, benevolent heart of God has not, as it were, wept tears of blood over you; it is not that He would not put His loving arms around you this moment, if you would only come to His feet, and confess you were wrong, and seek His pardon; but, otherwise, He may not—He cannot. The laws of His universe are against Him doing so. The good, it may be, of millions of immortal beings, is involved. He dare not, and He cannot, until there is a change of mind in you. You must repent. “Except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish.”

    Well, if repentance be an indispensable condition of salvation, let us glance at it for a moment, and try to find out what repentance really is; and, oh! how full of confusion the world and the church are upon this subject! I say it, because I know it by converse with hundreds of people. May the Holy Spirit help us!

    Well, first, repentance is not merely conviction of sin. Oh! if it only were, what a different world we should have to-night, for there are tens of thousands on whose hearts God’s Spirit has done His office by convincing them of sin. I am afraid we should be perfectly alarmed, astounded, confounded, if we had any conception of the multitudes whom God has convinced of sin, as He did Agrippa and Festus. Oh! I could not tell you the numbers of people, who, in our anxious meetings, have grasped my hand, and said, “Oh! what would I give to feel as I once felt! There was a time, fifteen, or seventeen, or twenty years ago,” and so on, “when I was so deeply convinced of sin that I could scarcely sleep, or eat—that I could find no rest; but, instead of going on till I found peace, I got diverted, cooled down, and now, I feel as hard as a stone.” I am afraid there are tens of thousands in this condition—once convinced of sin.

    There are thousands of others, who are convinced now. They say, “Yes, it is true what the minister says. I know I ought to lay down the weapons of my warfare against God; I know I ought to cut off this right hand, and pluck out this right eye.” They are convinced of sin, but they go no further. That is not repentance. They live this week as they did last. There is no response to the Spirit; they resist the Holy Ghost.

    Neither is repentance mere sorrow for sin. I have seen people weep bitterly, and writhe and struggle, but yet hug on to their idols, and in vain you try to shake them from them. Oh! if Jesus Christ would have saved them with those idols, they would have no objection at all. If they could have got through the strait gate with this one particular idol, they would have gone through long since; but to part with that—that is another thing. Such people will weep like your stubborn child, when you want him to do something which he does not want to do. He will cry, and when you apply the rod he will cry harder, but he will not yield. When he yields, he becomes a penitent; but, until he does, he is merely a convicted sinner. When God applies the rod of His Spirit, the rod of His providence, the rod of His Word, sinners will cry, and wince, and whine, and make you believe they are praying, and want to be saved, but all the while they are holding their necks as stiff as iron. They will not submit. The moment they submit, they become true penitents, and get saved. There is no mistake more common than for people to suppose they are penitents when they are not. There are some of you in this condition, I know. I am afraid you are quite mistaken—you are not penitents. God is true though every man should be a liar; and, if you had sought, as you say you have, and perhaps, think you have; if you had been sincere and honest with God, you would have been saved years ago. Oh! may God, the Holy Spirit, help you to come out and be HONEST. That is what God wants—that you be honest. “Oh,” says He, “why cover ye my altar with tears, and bring your vain oblations? Just be honest, and I will be honest with you and bless you; but while you come before Me and weep and profess, and bring the halt, and the maimed, and the blind, a curse be upon you.” He looks at you afar off. Be honest. Repentance is not mere sorrow for sin. You may be ever so sorry, and all the way down to death be hugging on to some forbidden possession, as was the young ruler. That is not repentance.

    Neither is repentance a promise that you will forsake sin in the future. Oh! if it were, there would be many penitents here to-night. There is scarcely a poor drunkard that does not promise, in his own mind, or to his poor wife, or somebody, that he will forsake his cups. There is scarcely any kind of a sinner that does not continually promise that he will give up his sin, and serve God, but he does not do it.

    Then what is repentance? Repentance is simply renouncing sin—turning round from darkness to light—from the power of Satan unto God. This is giving up sin in your heart, in purpose, in intention, in desire, resolving that you will give up every evil thing, and DO IT NOW. Of course, this involves sorrow, for how will any sane man turn himself round from a given course into another, if he does not repent having taken that course? It implies, also, hatred of, sin. He hates the course he formerly took, and turns round from it. He is like the prodigal, when he sat in the swine-yard amongst the husks and the filth, he fully resolved, and at last he acts. He went, and that was the test of his penitence! He might have sat resolving and promising till now, if he had lived as long, and he would never have got the father’s kiss, the father’s welcome, if he had not started; but he went. He left the filth, the swine-yard, the husks—he trampled them under his feet; he left the citizen of that country, and gave up all his subterfuges and excuses, and went to his father honestly, and said, “I have sinned!” which implied a great deal more in his language then than it does in ours now. “I have sinned against Heaven, and before thee;” and then comes the proof of his submission, “and am no more worthy to be called thy son: make me as one of thy hired servants”—put me in a stable, or set me to clean the boots, so that I can be in thy family and have thy smile. That is repentance—Jesus Christ’s own beautiful illustration of true penitence. Have you done that? Have you forsaken the accursed thing? Have you cut off that particular thing which the Holy Spirit has revealed to you? Is the “but” the hindrance that keeps you out of the Kingdom? You know what it is, and you will never get saved until you renounce it. Submission is the test of penitence. My child may be willing to do a hundred and fifty other things, but, if he is not willing to submit on the one point of controversy, he is a rebel, and remains one until he yields.

    Now, here is just the difference between a spurious and a real repentance. I am afraid we have thousands in our churches who had a spurious repentance: they were convinced of sin—they were sorry for it; they wanted to live a better life, to love God in a sort of general way; but they skipped over the real point of controversy with God; they hid it from their pastor, perhaps, and from the deacons, and from the people who talked with them.

    Now, I say, Abraham might have been willing to have given up every other thing that he possessed; but, if he had not been willing to give up Isaac, all else would have been useless. It is your Isaac God wants. You have got an Isaac, just as the young ruler had his possessions. You have got something that you are holding on to, that the Holy Spirit says you must let go, and you say, “I can’t.” Very well; then you must stop outside the kingdom. I beseech you, do not deceive yourselves by supposing that you repent, for you do not; but, oh! my dear friends, let me beseech you to repent. The apostle says, “Knowing therefore the terror of the Lord, we persuade men;” and this is, I believe, the greatest work of the ministry. To do what? To persuade men to submit. We are constantly talking to thousands of people who know just what God wants of them. We cannot bring many of them any new light or new Gospel. They know all about it. They used to tell me that so often, that I longed for a congregation of heathen, which I have found since then. Consequently, when they hear the Gospel, like the publicans and sinners of old, they go into the kingdom, while such as some of you who are the natural children of the kingdom, are shut out, because when they hear they receive, and submit, and obey, while you stand outside and hold on to your idols, and reason, and quibble, and reject! My dear friends, let me persuade you to trample under foot that idol, to tear down that refuge of lies, and to come to God honestly, and say, “Lord, here I am, to be a servant, to be nothing, to do anything, to suffer anything. I know I shall be happier with Thy smile and Thy blessing than all these evil things now make me without Thee.” When you come to a full surrender, my friends, you will get what you have been seeking, some of you, for years.

    But then another difficulty comes in, and people say, “I have not the power to repent.” Oh! yes, you have. That is a grand mistake. You have the power, or God would not command it. You can repent. You can this moment lift up your eyes to Heaven, and say, with the prodigal, “Father, I have sinned, and I renounce my sin.” You may not be able to weep—God nowhere requires or commands that; but you are able, this very moment, to renounce sin, in purpose, in resolution, in intention. Mind, don’t confound the renouncing of the sin, with the power of saving yourself from it. If you renounce it, Jesus will come and save you from it. Like the man with the withered hand—Jesus intended to heal that man. Where was the power to come from to heal him? From Jesus, of course. The benevolence, the love, that prompted that healing, all came from Jesus; but Jesus wanted a condition. What was it? The response of the man’s will; and so He said, “Stretch forth thy hand.” If he had been like some of you, he would have said, “What an unreasonable command! You know I cannot do it—I cannot.” Some of you say that; but I say you can, and you will have to do it, or you will be lost. What did Jesus want? He wanted that, “I will, Lord,” inside the man—the response of his will. He wanted him to say, “Yes, Lord;” and, the moment he said that, Jesus supplied strength, and he stretched it forth, and you know what happened.

    Don’t look forward, and say, “I shall not have strength;” that is not your matter—that is His. He will hold you up;—He is able, when you once commit yourself to Him. Now then, say, “I will.” Never mind what you suffer—it shall be done. He will pour in the oil and balm. His glorious, blessed presence will do more for you in one hour, than all your struggling, praying, and wrestling have done all these weary years. He will lift you up out of the pit. You are in the mire now, and the more you struggle the more you sink; but He will lift you out of it, and put your feet on the rock, and then you will stand firm. Stretch out your withered hand, whatever it may be;—say, “I will, Lord.” You have the power, and mind, you have the obligation, which is universal and immediate. God “now commandeth all men everywhere to repent,” and to believe the Gospel. What a tyrant He must be if He commands that, and yet He knows you have not the power!

    Now, do you repent? Mind the old snare. Not, do you weep? The feeling will come after the surrender.

    Now, do not say, “I do not feel enough.” Do you feel enough to be willing to forsake your sin? that is the point. Any soul who does not repent enough to forsake his sin, is not a penitent at all! When you repent enough to forsake your sin, that moment your repentance is sincere, and you may take hold of Jesus with a firm grasp. You have a right to appropriate the promise, then it is “look and live.” “Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved.”

    Will you come to that point now? Don’t begin making an excuse. Now!—all men! everywhere!—NOW! Oh! my friend, if you had done that ten years ago! You have been accumulating sin, condemnation, and wrath ever since. God commanded you these ten years to repent, and believe the Gospel, and here you are yet. How many sermons have you heard?—invitations rejected? How much blessed persuasion and reasoning of the Holy Spirit have you resisted?—how much of the grace of God have you received in vain? I tremble to think what an accumulated load of abused privilege, lost opportunity, and wasted influence, such people will have to give an account of. Talk about hell!—the weight of this will be hell enough. You don’t seem to think anything of the way you treat God. Oh! people are very much awake to any evil they do to their fellow-men. They can much more easily see the sin of ruining or injuring their neighbors than injuring the great God; but He says, “Will a man rob God? Yet ye have robbed me.” Do you not see; the awful weight of condemnation that comes upon you for putting off, rejecting, resisting, vascilating, halting, while He says, Now—now? He has had a right to every breath you have drawn, to all your influence, every hour, of every day of all your years. Is it not time you ended that controversy? He may do with you as He did with such people once before—swear in His wrath that you shall not enter into His rest. Are you not provoking Him as they provoked Him? Oh! my friend, be persuaded now to repent. Let your sin go away, and come to the feet of Jesus. For your own sake be persuaded. For the peace, the joy, the power, the glory, the gladness of living a life of consecration to God, and service to your fellow-men, yield; but most of all, for the love He bears you, submit.

    A great, rough man (stricken down), said to my husband, a few weeks ago, when he looked up to the place where other people were being saved, “Mr. Booth, I would not go there for a hundred pounds!” My husband whispered, “Will you go there for love?” and, after a minute’s hesitation, the man, brushing the great tears away, rose up, and followed him.

    Will you go there for love—the love of Jesus!—the great love wherewith He loved you and gave Himself for you? Will you, for the great yearning with which your Father has been following you all these years—for His love’s sake, will you come? Go down at His feet and submit. The Lord help you! Amen.

  2. Benjamin Winter Avatar
    Benjamin Winter

    Jeff, thank you for this beautiful reflection! I was really encouraged by your thoughts on the centrality of repentance. Reminded me of an excellent sermon the same topic by Catherine Booth: http://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/6669/pg6669.html (chapter 1)

Leave a Reply

Conciliar Post

Conciliar Post is an online community and archive devoted to thoughtful Christian reflection. Since its founding, the site has published theological conversations, reflections on Christianity, reviews, and commentary on culture and current events from a Christian perspective.

Top Posts

The Old Testament in OrderDecember 13, 2024Jacob Prahlow
The New Testament in OrderApril 14, 2021Jacob Prahlow
How the Christ Defined the ChristianAugust 15, 2025Matthew Bryan
The Phoebe ProblemFebruary 16, 2022Jacob Prahlow
A Brief History of Communion (Part I)February 14, 2017Jacob Prahlow

Discover more from Conciliar Post

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading