How Should the Church Treat Singles?

“Another one bites the dust” is the relationship theme song I resonate with lately. I can barely go a month without one of my friends telling me they are dating or engaged. I have been in—or behind the scenes of—quite a few weddings in the last year or two. This is not the first round of this life-season for me. It happened a couple of years after high school, again after my higher education terms, and now that many friends are approaching their late twenties and thirties. There have been quite a few seasons of babies among my friends, too. It is a constant ebb and flow.

None of this is surprising—it is the rhythm of life. It feels new and exciting and surreal when it happens to you or your closest friends, but it sounds pretty normal to everyone else. What might sound abnormal to some is that I am pleased for my friends, but I don’t want to be in their shoes. Oh, I have twinges of unfulfilled hopes when I watch the father-daughter dance at weddings. I am human, I want someone to go through life with—to care about and to be vulnerable with. Sappy songs make me sad every now and then. Sometimes I feel at loose ends, like I should have someone to share something with, but they aren’t there. The longing to be loved is natural, put in our hearts by Divine Love himself.

More often than not, however, I am thankful to be single. Singleness is not synonymous with loneliness. This truth often seems to evade people—especially church people. They ask some strange questions at times, and snarky me replies in my head (well-taught-me answers with much more tact). The one I hear most often rings hollow to me, “About the time I became content with my singleness, I met my spouse.” Strange, I think to myself, I’ve been contentedly, cheerfully, single for many years and ‘Poof!’ I have no husband. Thanks for sharing without caring to enquire whether or not I enjoy being single. Every now and then someone will tell me (none-too-subtly) they would like me to meet their son, though no one has ever followed through on helping such a meeting to take place. Now, I’m not opposed to getting married, it simply isn’t my calling at this point—I am quite satisfied with all that I have and am called to right now.

Words upon words have been written about relationships—both the dating kind and all others (as if those are the only two categories there are). I have heard plenty of married people tell me they wished they had enjoyed their single years while they had them. Many a single friend has told me of their ache to be married. That pain is real, I understand. Usually, I choose not to add my voice to those conversations, as they have been had many times already by people who are wiser than I am.

Rather, I choose to opine about feeling like someone who grew a third head on the spot, or like the Invisible Man at various church gatherings. How should the church treat singles? For starters, it would help not to be pitied or unseen. Singleness isn’t a disease. It would also be great if people wouldn’t ask all those frustrating questions—”Have you tried online dating?”—as if I were dying to get married, or am unaware of how to meet people of the opposite sex. If you are so concerned, invite a few unmarried men and women over for dinner so they can spend time together comfortably. It would be a relief not to be “singled” out—either made an outcast or lumped into groups of other single people. What I am trying to say is that it would be helpful if singles were treated simply as human beings, not as ‘singles’. We are persons, not slices of Kraft cheese.

Churches that don’t have a singles’ group receive my mental applause. The ones that have small groups of mixed ages are hailed with gratitude. How will I ever learn what marriage is if I don’t see it lived out in front of me (in others besides my parents)? Peer groups often feel like the blind leading the blind. I need folks who are older and wiser than I am speaking into my life, telling me their stories, sharing their wisdom and what God is teaching them through Scripture. I have friends in their forties, fifties, and sixties with whom I love spending a long evening—to hear and to share about life and Godliness. I probably need more of these friends. These are the friends who share their homes, their meals, their thoughts on literature and society—the friends who open the Word of God to me.

We are all human beings first. Yes, we are male or female. Married or unmarried. Old or young. Gifted in this or gifted in that. Dichotomies aside, however, we are all in need of Love, of Beauty, of being made Holy as God is Holy. We all need Truth to anchor our lives. We need our family and friends. We need to give and to receive—graciously, humbly. We need stillness and the sounds of life. We need time alone and time in fellowship. We all need Jesus.

Why focus on the things that divide us? Perhaps that is the reason I don’t like being labelled “single”—or “female” or “white” or whatever other label people try to stick on each other. Certain identifiers I will accept—such as “Christian” or “writer” or “sister” or “friend”—because those things unite me with vast amounts of people. It is not an us-against-them sort of life. Life that truly is life is lived together—and that is much harder than separating off into our little factions or comfortable autonomy, isn’t it?

9 responses to “Refusing to be ‘Singled’ Out”

  1. Lila Toney Fair Avatar
    Lila Toney Fair

    Beautifully written. I married at 46, and throughout the years of being single, I saw great changes in the way churches respond to singles. When I was a child, our family sort of “adopted” a missionary– a single woman who worked as a Bible translator. My friends’ family “adopted” a nun. We would include them in family outings, special events, even family reunions. Singleness was considered both good and necessary to the lives and callings of these women.
    When I was a young adult, I wasn’t too bothered by the subtle pressure to adhere to a culturally imposed idea of womanhood that required early marriage and children. But the church seemed confused by the number of singles in their mid-to late twenties–this was a newer cultural trend, and one the church handled awkwardly– several churches developed “college and career” groups. I attended some of them as a college student, but “singles” events and groups seemed to be divided between the “bachelors ’til the rapture” types who were not waiting to marry, but were actively opposed to marriage and just wanted to socialize with others who had no spouses or kids; and the “desperate daters” who were convinced that the right mate was someone else in that particular group, and that someone else would get “their” mate if they missed even one event. The problem with such groups was that the entire focus was on singlehood–NOT Christian living, Bible study, community service, discipleship… oh, the materials were supposed to be Bible-based, but they all focused on how a single person could “still” be a useful member of the Kingdom, as though singleness rendered us less skilled, less committed, or less accepted. I tried not to let this mindset seep into my own thinking, but it could be difficult at times, with fellow church members concluding that I should have been married before age 30; that singleness was some sort of rebellion against God, or that I was, in some way, “unnatural”.
    As I entered my thirties and early forties, the trend among churches was to create cell groups–groups that took turns meeting in homes to create a greater sense of community. The groups usually did Bible studies, but they also socialized and fellowshipped…and even though they tried to include people of different age groups, they were never quite sure what to do with singles. Many of the Bible studies dealt with marriage and family issues–often requiring a partner for some of the activities or questions. And our Sunday School classes were often divided into “life stages”– newlyweds and young parents, studies on womanhood/manhood, parenting teens, “empty nesters”, seniors–it was assumed that I would go to the womanhood study, yet the study would invariably be focused on marriage and motherhood, with an aside for young singles who would “soon” need this advise, and another aside for those doggedly determined old maids (they weren’t this cruel in their description, but there was a palpable tone of frustration that we didn’t fit the “norm”.)
    I see the trend turning back (hopefully) to the way things were when I was younger. I think after years of getting confused between Biblical identity and cultural identity, the Church is getting better about recognizing that we are all loved and valued equally by the King we all serve.

    1. Jody Byrkett Avatar

      Lila, thank you for sharing this… I appreciate the insight into your own life, as well as the hope that change can take place. I love the practise of including single men and women into one’s family events—I saw this happen a lot more in my growing up years and in the more community-living Midwest culture. My own family certainly sought to include a particular single gal from our church, as well as a young family who had no relatives in the state.

      I confess, it can be difficult as a person without any family nearby to know how to interact with other families. I don’t want to invite myself over to others’ homes all the time, but it often seems easier if I bring part of the meal and go to others, as there is just one me. I certainly enjoy opening my home to others, but it is small and a bit limited… So sometimes I get intimidated from having others over. Guess I need to get over that. 😉

      Do you have any advice for how unmarried men and women can help change the current of Bible studies to be more Christ-focussed, rather than life-events focussed? I know, our culture likes to parcel things out into groups, and if you don’t fit in that group they are at a loss as to what to do with you… But I guess I want to poke culture and tell the church that that approach isn’t really Biblical. I’ve been a bit of a rebel that way… but in more recent years I’ve mostly withdrawn from organised studies/groups and sought out more one-on-one interactions with Godly people that I know.

  2. mmchanb Avatar
    mmchanb

    Amen, Johanna! I personally go one further. That is to say that although I am happily married, I agree with Paul that singleness is the better mode for those who are devoted in faith. I would like to hear churches exalt the better mode. Great article!

    1. Jody Byrkett Avatar

      Matthew, I am curious to hear a little more here… I agree that singleness has its freedom and that being single means you don’t feel the dual-focus of serving God and the weight of responsibility of providing for/leading/teaching one’s family… (Though there are plenty of things that can snatch anyone’s focus from God, single or married.) Yet I also know marriage is a good gift from God. How does one who is married balance serving God whole-heartedly while being responsible for family concerns? And more to your point, if singleness is the better mode, is that more directed at those in ministry (say pastors or missionaries)?

    2. Jody Byrkett Avatar

      Matthew, I am curious to hear a little more here… I agree that singleness has its freedom and that being single means you don’t feel the dual-focus of serving God and the weight of responsibility of providing for/leading/teaching one’s family… (Though there are plenty of things that can snatch anyone’s focus from God, single or married.) Yet I also know marriage is a good gift from God. How does one who is married balance serving God whole-heartedly while being responsible for family concerns? And more to your point, if singleness is the better mode, is that more directed at those in ministry (say pastors or missionaries)?

  3. Alyssa Hall Avatar
    Alyssa Hall

    Applause to you Jody! My sentiments exactly! My singleness is such a gift and I delight in the freedom I have to give and serve wherever, whenever. And yes, I’ve heard the line about finding your spouse right after finding contentment.. it makes me chuckle! My thinking is that my life, my will, my purpose is not determined by me, but ordained by the Lord. And He has given me a thankful, joyful heart to make the very most of each opportunity-including singleness! So, why would I desire anything else until He moves me to a different place in life? And I absolutely agree that the church needs to rediscover the tool that singles can be in advancing the kingdom of God! By the way, during your experiences with Summit, did you hear the tired refrain of how everyone meets their spouse there? It’s pretty funny how often I heard people telling me that-it made it seem like a dating service! 😉

    1. Jody Byrkett Avatar

      Alyssa, exactly! Singleness isn’t a curse, rather, it is a blessing of freedom to serve God and others anytime. I always appreciated Elisabeth Elliot saying that singleness is a gift and marriage is a gift, and we should be thankful for whichever gift God has given us—even if one replaces the other.

      Haha, oh yes, it does feel like a dating service sometimes. I have worked with Summit (either as summer staff or year-round staff) for ten years now… I smile and tell people that after all these years I haven’t met my spouse at Summit and I’m okay with that. That isn’t the purpose of Summit—though it is a blessing to the many who have met their spouse here, I know. 🙂

  4. Charles Heyworth Avatar

    Johanna, I really appreciate your encouragement to pursue small group relationships that include individuals of all ages. When I was leading a young adult community, we made some intentional efforts to make opportunities for these kinds of relationships, but it was sometimes difficult because of work, kids, and the difference in lifestyle. What advice do you have for how churches (or individuals) could facilitate more cross-generational connection like you describe here?

    1. Jody Byrkett Avatar

      That’s a good question… One thing that opened up those cross-generational doors for me was the hospitality of a couple my parents’ age who sat next to me in church. They invited me up to their home for tea one afternoon. We clicked and have been friends ever since. So, part of it comes from people being willing to open their homes without some formal group. It could have worked the other way (of course), where I invited them to my house first—if I had thought of it.

      The other thing that has succeeded in more than one church I have attended was what we called “rotating fellowship”—people of all ages sign up to be in a dinner groups for four month stretches. The coordinator mixes the groups with couples, singles, older, younger, whatever… There are at least four different homes involved per group, and each person/couple/family opens their home once in that four month time to host the others. Even if you had to miss one dinner, you still got to know the folks in your group because you had a couple more chances to meet with them. One of the best questions one of the hosts asked in one of my groups was for everyone to share their testimony/faith journey.

      I don’t know how to encourage big churches to pursue mixed-age Bible studies… That seems to work better in the smaller churches I’ve been to. At which point, everyone meets together for the study because there are only so many people.

      I think the biggest problem in our culture is that we’re all so busy all the time… It makes actually spending time with people rather difficult. It makes spontaneity difficult rather than a joy. If you can suggest a way to help our culture slow down that might help change some of the separation we find in churches.

Leave a Reply

Conciliar Post

Conciliar Post is an online community and archive devoted to thoughtful Christian reflection. Since its founding, the site has published theological conversations, reflections on Christianity, reviews, and commentary on culture and current events from a Christian perspective.

Top Posts

The Old Testament in OrderDecember 13, 2024Jacob Prahlow
The New Testament in OrderApril 14, 2021Jacob Prahlow
How the Christ Defined the ChristianAugust 15, 2025Matthew Bryan
Why Liturgy?December 2, 2016Wesley Walker
John Wesley and Small GroupsFebruary 17, 2020Jarrett Dickey

Discover more from Conciliar Post

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading